EPISODE 71: When Concussion Symptoms Don’t Go Away: Kristen McCarthy’s Journey Back to Life
By Dr. Ja’nae Brown, PT, DPT
Physical Therapy San Pedro
When a Concussion Changes Everything: Kristen McCarthy’s Story of Recovery and Life After Basketball
When most athletes hear the word concussion, they think about missing a game, sitting out for a week or two, and then getting back to their sport.
But what happens when the symptoms don't go away?
This is something I see in my practice when treating patients with concussions, and unfortunately, this became the reality for one of my patients, former professional basketball player Kristen McCarthy.
In honor of Concussion Awareness Month, I sat down with Kristen for Episode 71 of the PTSP Podcast to talk about her experience with post-concussion syndrome, her rehabilitation, and what life looks like for her today.
I wanted to share Kristen's story because it highlights something I think is incredibly important for athletes, parents, coaches, and even healthcare providers to understand:
We cannot take concussions lightly.
Too many athletes sustain a concussion and never receive the appropriate follow-up care. Unfortunately, for some, this can lead to persistent symptoms that significantly impact their quality of life.
My goal with this podcast episode was to educate athletes about the importance of recognizing concussion symptoms, taking action, and seeking care early. The care you receive after a concussion can make a difference in your recovery, and Kristen's story is an important example of why this matters.
Let's dive into her story.
One Game That Changed Everything
Kristen was playing professional basketball overseas in Iceland when she sustained a concussion during an important game in a championship series.
She took a direct hit to the head, but at the time, her symptoms didn't seem severe. There was also no medical professional on the sideline to assess her and advise her whether it was safe to continue playing.
So, like many competitive athletes would, she went back into the game to finish the last couple of minutes.
Later that night, Kristen went to the emergency room to get evaluated. After being assessed by a physician in Iceland, she was cleared to continue playing.
Kristen admits that although she told the physician she had a mild headache, she also advocated for herself to be able to play in the remaining championship games.
And this is something I think a lot of athletes can relate to.
When you have worked your entire season to get to a championship game, the last thing you want to hear is that you can't play.
Kristen remembers feeling a little off during the next game, but she actually played well.
Unfortunately, shortly afterward, everything came crashing down.
Her symptoms began to increase significantly, and she felt awful. She ended up spending about a week in bed, struggling with symptoms while also trying to figure out how she was going to get back home now that her season had ended.
Once she returned home, she was on a mission to get better. Her goal was to recover and return to professional basketball the following season.
But her symptoms weren't going away.
Six Months Later, She Ended Up in My Office
By the time Kristen came to see me at Physical Therapy San Pedro, it had been approximately six months since her concussion.
Six months!
I want to emphasize something here: Time matters when it comes to concussion care.
The first several days following a concussion are an important part of recovery. We also know that early assessment, appropriate activity modification, and timely rehabilitation can help improve outcomes.
This is why I encourage athletes to seek care from a healthcare professional who understands concussion management rather than simply waiting weeks or months for their symptoms to disappear.
By the time Kristen came to my practice, she was no longer in the acute phase of her injury. She was experiencing persistent symptoms that were affecting her ability to function and return to the activities she loved.
And this is where concussion can become incredibly frustrating.
An athlete may look completely normal on the outside, but internally, they may be dealing with headaches, dizziness, fatigue, difficulty concentrating, exercise intolerance, visual problems, sensitivity to light or sound, sleep disturbances, and other symptoms that make everyday activities difficult.
This is one of the reasons concussion is often described as an invisible injury.
There may not be a brace, cast, or obvious physical injury for someone else to see.
But that doesn't make the symptoms any less real.
Concussion Rehabilitation Is More Than Rest
One of the biggest misconceptions I still hear about concussions is that the treatment is simply to go home, rest in a dark room, avoid activity, and wait until you feel better.
That is not how we should be managing concussions today.
Research has changed the way we approach concussion recovery. While relative rest is important during the first 24–48 hours, prolonged complete rest and avoiding all activity are generally not recommended.
In fact, appropriately prescribed physical activity and rehabilitation can play an important role in recovery.
When I evaluate someone with persistent concussion symptoms, I'm not just interested in whether they still have a headache.
I want to know ALL of their symptoms.
There are 22 symptoms included in a commonly used concussion symptom assessment, and understanding how those symptoms are affecting someone is only the beginning.
I also want to know:
How are their eyes working?
How is their balance?
How does their vestibular system respond to movement?
Is their neck contributing to their headaches or dizziness?
What happens when their heart rate increases?
Can they tolerate exercise?
Can they look at a screen without symptoms?
Can they walk through a busy environment without becoming symptomatic?
Can they perform a physical task while also processing information?
And most importantly, what is keeping this particular person from getting back to their life?
That is where individualized concussion rehabilitation becomes so important.
Kristen's Rehabilitation Was a Process
During our podcast conversation, Kristen and I talked about what rehabilitation actually looked like for her.
It wasn't one exercise or one magical treatment.
It was a process.
Her rehabilitation addressed the different systems contributing to her symptoms, and we gradually challenged those systems as she improved.
Depending on the individual, concussion rehabilitation may include vestibular exercises, balance training, visual exercises, cervical spine treatment, graded aerobic exercise, symptom-management strategies, and a progressive return to normal activities.
And sometimes, physical therapy is only one piece of the puzzle.
Kristen needed additional care outside of our clinic during her recovery, and I think this is something important to talk about.
Persistent concussion symptoms can be complicated. There can be several different factors contributing to why someone isn't getting better.
As healthcare providers, we need to recognize when another specialist needs to become part of the team.
Concussion recovery may involve collaboration with physicians, neurologists, vision specialists, mental health professionals, and other healthcare providers depending on the person's symptoms and needs.
Good concussion care isn't about one provider trying to fix everything. It's about figuring out what that individual needs to recover.
Recovery Is Not Always a Straight Line
This is another message I want athletes to hear.
Recovery is not always linear.
You can have several great days and then suddenly have a day when your symptoms flare up.
That doesn't automatically mean you're back at the beginning.
Part of concussion rehabilitation is learning how much activity your body and brain can tolerate, gradually increasing that capacity, and understanding how to respond when symptoms increase.
For someone who is used to being a high-level athlete, this can be incredibly challenging.
Athletes are trained to push.
They're trained to work through discomfort.
They're trained to compete.
But concussion recovery sometimes requires a different approach.
You have to learn when to push, when to modify, and when to listen to what your body is telling you.
And that can be difficult for an athlete who is used to pushing through everything.
What Does Recovery Really Mean?
Kristen eventually got back to doing most of the things she wanted and needed to do in her everyday life.
But she did not return to professional basketball.
And I think this part of her story is important.
In sports medicine, we spend a lot of time talking about return to sport.
When can they run?
When can they practice?
When can they compete?
When are they cleared?
These are all important questions, but they're not the only measures of a successful recovery.
Sometimes success means being able to exercise again.
Drive again.
Work again.
Travel.
Spend time with your family.
Walk into a busy environment without symptoms.
Coach.
Train athletes.
Enjoy your life again.
For Kristen, basketball is still very much a part of her life.
Today, she continues to train athletes, lead basketball camps, mentor young players, and share her knowledge and love for the game.
Her relationship with basketball changed, but her impact on the sport didn't end when her professional playing career did.
And I love that part of her story.
Kristen's Advice to Other Athletes
One of my favorite parts of our conversation was hearing Kristen speak directly to athletes who may be dealing with a concussion.
Her message was simple:
Your career is longer than one game.
Sit out. Get evaluated. Take the time you need to recover, even if you think your injury is minor.
She also encourages athletes to seek care from someone who understands concussions and to trust the recovery process.
As a physical therapist who treats concussions, I couldn't agree more.
There is no game, practice, tournament, or season worth ignoring a brain injury.
And I know that's hard to hear when you're an athlete who has worked so hard to compete.
But the decisions you make after a concussion can have consequences that extend far beyond that game or season.
My Message to Athletes and Parents
If there is one thing I want you to take away from Kristen's story, it's this:
Don't ignore concussion symptoms, and don't wait until they become persistent to seek help.
If you suspect you or your athlete has sustained a concussion, remove them from play and have them evaluated by an appropriately trained healthcare professional.
And if it has been weeks or even months and you still don't feel like yourself, please know that there may be more that can be done.
You may need your vestibular system assessed.
You may need your vision evaluated.
Your neck may be contributing to your symptoms.
You may need a structured return-to-exercise program.
You may need another specialist involved.
Or you may simply need someone to look at the entire picture and help determine what is preventing you from moving forward.
Every concussion is different, and every individual responds differently.
That is why concussion rehabilitation should never be a one-size-fits-all approach.
Sometimes Recovery Means Getting Your Life Back
Kristen's journey didn't end with her returning to professional basketball.
It ended with something different.
She got her life back.
She returned to the game in a new way—as a trainer, mentor, coach, and leader for the next generation of basketball players.
And that is why I wanted to share her story.
As a sports physical therapist, I love helping athletes get back to their sport. But even more importantly, I want them to be able to live healthy, active lives long after their playing days are over.
Recovery doesn't always mean returning to exactly where you were before your injury.
Sometimes it means finding a new way forward.
And that matters just as much.
Watch or Listen to Kristen's Full Story
You can hear my full conversation with Kristen McCarthy on Episode 71 of the PTSP Podcast.
We discuss her concussion, post-concussion syndrome, what rehabilitation looked like for her, the additional treatments she needed, life after professional basketball, and the advice she has for other athletes.
Watch Episode 71 on YouTube or listen on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, Amazon Music, or wherever you listen to podcasts.
Connect With Kristen McCarthy
Kristen McCarthy is a former professional basketball player, mentor, trainer, coach, and youth speaker.
Website: www.kmathletes.com
Instagram: @kris10mccarthy5
Facebook: Kristen McCarthy
Need Help After a Concussion?
If you or your athlete is experiencing symptoms after a concussion, Physical Therapy San Pedro provides specialized concussion evaluation and rehabilitation.
Our goal isn't simply to get athletes back on the field, court, or dance floor.
We want to help them get back to life.
Contact Physical Therapy San Pedro to learn more about our concussion rehabilitation services or schedule an evaluation.
This article is for educational purposes and is not a substitute for individualized medical evaluation or treatment.
If you’re in the San Pedro or Los Angeles area and looking for some help, we are a practice that reflects these values — individualized care, intentional programming, and long-term performance. We’d love to work with you at Physical Therapy San Pedro.
For those outside the area, we also offer telehealth sessions and online programs focused on ankle and knee pain, designed for athletes who want to keep progressing no matter where they’re located.
Stay Connected & Take the Next Step
📅 Book an in-person or virtual session at Physical Therapy San Pedro
📸 IG / FB: @physicaltherapysanpedro
📺 YouTube: Physical Therapy San Pedro
🎙️ Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or wherever you get your podcasts.
📞 (424) 536-3023
📍 415 W 6th Street, San Pedro, CA 90731
Stay strong. Stay moving.
❤️ Dr. Brown




Comments