top of page

EPISODE 72: "7 Hills We'll Die On as Sports PTs"

Nov 11
6 min read

Dr. Ja'nae Brown, PT, DPT


You've heard it all before. Ice it, rest it, stretch it, or just push through the pain. But how much of that advice is actually helping you get better?


As a sports physical therapist, I frequently work with athletes who have misconceptions about injuries and what it actually takes to recover. Some believe that once their pain disappears, they're fully healed. Others assume that an MRI showing a tear automatically means surgery is their only option.


The truth is, injury recovery isn't always that straightforward. But there are some things we feel pretty strongly about as Sports PTs!


In recognition of National Physical Therapy Month, we're sharing 7 Hills We'll Die On as Sports PTs, challenging some of the most common injury and rehabilitation myths that may be holding you back from making a full recovery.


We're separating fact from fiction, sharing what we've learned through years of clinical experience, and helping you better understand what your body actually needs to recover.


Let's get into it!


Hill #1: Rest Is Not Always the Answer.

The truth is, if it hurts for longer than a week, you need help. Rest alone isn't going to change it. Sometimes we need a few days to recover from a hard workout, a tournament, a big match or competition, or even something new we tried. But most of the time, I think we know when we need help and just choose to ignore it. Don't put off getting help. Small things can turn into big things. Oftentimes, we just need to teach you a few things and get you moving in a way that feels good again.

Educational Takeaway: Rest may help initially, but progressive movement and loading are often essential to recovery.


Hill #2: Ice Is Not a Magic Healing Tool.

Ice may feel good and help reduce pain, but research isn't showing that it actually speeds up tissue healing. We tell our patients that if using an ice pack keeps you from having to take a pain pill, then it can be beneficial. But the key to recovery is movement and progressive loading.

Educational Takeaway: Ice can help manage pain, but pain relief doesn't necessarily mean faster tissue healing.


Hill #3: An MRI Finding Doesn't Automatically Mean You Need Surgery

We've discussed this many times in previous episodes. Imaging can show tears in ligaments and tendons, but that doesn't necessarily mean surgery is needed. Many findings on imaging can be managed through rehabilitation. When an injury isn't responding to physical therapy or requires further evaluation, we'll refer you to a surgeon. Research continues to support a rehab-first approach for many musculoskeletal injuries, with physical therapy playing an important role in achieving the best possible outcomes.

Educational Takeaway: Imaging findings alone don't determine whether surgery is necessary.


Hill #4: Not Every Tight Muscle Needs to Be Stretched.

Sometimes your muscles are truly tight. Believe me, we see it every day in the clinic! But sometimes, you may actually be extremely flexible and still feel that sensation of "tightness" after a hard workout, tournament, performance, competition, or a series of practices, training sessions, and games.

What you're perceiving as tightness may actually be muscle soreness, fatigue, or a muscle group that's been overworked or overloaded. If you continue to feel tight, you're already pretty flexible, and stretching isn't helping, there's probably something else going on that needs to be addressed.

Educational Takeaway: Tightness isn't always a flexibility problem. Strength and load tolerance may also play a role.


Hill #5: Pain-Free Does NOT Mean Game-Ready.

This is a big one for us! We all want to be pain-free, and we tend to think that once the pain is gone, we can go right back to the activity that was causing us pain in the first place, like running. But that's not the case. Being pain-free is usually just the beginning. Once your pain is gone, your body is better able to start taking on the loads needed to get you back to that activity, but this requires a graded progression. Going from pain-free straight back to running without properly preparing your body is a recipe for disaster. We have to progress from pain-free to building strength, power, agility, and speed. It's a process! If you return to your sport simply because you're pain-free, without doing the work to address the actual problem, you may find yourself right back in PT with a bigger problem or a more significant reinjury.

Educational Takeaway: Being pain-free doesn't automatically mean you're physically prepared for the demands of your sport.


Hill #6: Braces and Tape Are Not Substitutes for Rehabilitation.

Oh, we love this one at PTSP! We actually love taping and use different types of tape in the clinic for different reasons. Taping and bracing absolutely have their purpose. Ultimately, both are supportive tools that can help our patients get through games, competitions, and events they really want to participate in. But relying on taping and bracing without addressing the underlying problem can come at a cost. Your body is smart, and it knows what it can handle. If you consistently rely on taping or bracing without addressing why you need it in the first place, you may contribute to an ongoing injury or develop compensations elsewhere in your body. You have to ultimately address WHY you need to brace or tape. Period.

Educational Takeaway: Bracing and taping can provide benefits in specific situations, but neither replaces appropriate rehabilitation and conditioning.


Hill #7: Physical Therapy Is More Than a Sheet of Exercises.

PT is so much more than exercises on a piece of paper. This is where I think some healthcare groups are falling short. They treat everyone the same, handing out a list of exercises, and it makes physical therapy seem like it doesn't work. These same patients continue to struggle, searching for help, and eventually end up at our office, where they receive individualized care and finally start getting better. People need to be approached individually. They need session-to-session guidance and a graded progression of their program. One of the biggest challenges I see in PT is that physical therapists don't always spend enough time getting to know their patients, understanding what they need to be able to do, and educating them on activity tolerance. Sometimes, we also need to incorporate additional tools to assist with rehabilitation, such as manual therapy, cupping, taping, BFR, or NMES. These are all tools that can serve a purpose when used appropriately. Ultimately, we need to approach each patient as an individual, not just give everyone the same exercises and expect the same results.

Educational Takeaway: Effective physical therapy includes clinical assessment, individualized exercise prescription, progressive loading, education, and objective reassessment.


The Bottom Line: Recovery Is More Than Just Getting Rid of Pain!

If there's one thing I hope you take away from these seven hills, it's that injury recovery isn't about finding a quick fix. It's about understanding what's going on with your body, addressing the underlying problem, and doing the work to get back to the activities you love.


Rest, ice, stretching, taping, and even exercises all have their place, but none of them are a one-size-fits-all solution. Every athlete is different, every injury is different, and your rehabilitation should reflect that.


This National Physical Therapy Month, I encourage you to take an active role in your recovery. Ask questions, get educated, and don't settle for just being pain-free. Your goal should be to come back stronger, more confident, and better prepared for the demands of your sport. And that's a hill we'll ALWAYS die on at PTSP!


Struggling with an Injury? Let's Get You Back to Doing What You Love!

At Physical Therapy San Pedro, we believe recovery is about more than just getting rid of pain. It's about understanding your injury, addressing the underlying problem, and preparing your body for the demands of your sport and everyday life.


We combine evidence-based rehabilitation, individualized programming, progressive loading, and performance-focused training to help our athletes recover and return to doing what they love.


If you're in the San Pedro or Los Angeles area and looking for help with an injury, we'd love to work with you! Our team is committed to providing individualized care, educating our patients, and helping you build the strength and confidence to get back to your activities.


Don't let common injury myths hold you back. Get the right care, do the work, and let's get you moving!


For those outside the area, we also offer telehealth sessions and online programs focused on ankle and knee pain, designed for athletes who want to keep progressing no matter where they’re located.


Stay Connected & Take the Next Step

📅 Book an in-person or virtual session at Physical Therapy San Pedro

📸 IG / FB: @physicaltherapysanpedro

📺 YouTube: Physical Therapy San Pedro

🎙️ Listen on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, Amazon Music, or wherever you get your podcasts.

📞 (424) 536-3023

📍 415 W 6th Street, San Pedro, CA 90731


Move Well <=> Perform Well


❤️ Dr. Brown


 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page